The State of GameFi: From Hype to Utility
The GameFi industry's activity has plummeted to lows not seen since early 2023, with a 17% quarter-over-quarter drop in unique active wallets. This downturn is underscored by a shocking statistic: an estimated 93% of GameFi projects have failed or become inactive.
But this "Play-to-Earn apocalypse" is not an end but a necessary reset. It could force the sector to transition towards a more sustainable model that fixes its core flaws and focuses on attracting and retaining players for the long term.
This article will explore the state of the Web3 gaming market, how the GameFi industry has evolved from a hype-driven Play-to-Earn (P2E) model to more sustainable, utility-focused gaming experiences, and what trends are shaping its future.
The State of the GameFi Market
GameFi is the fusion of decentralised finance (DeFi) and gaming, a model where players can earn real economic value through blockchain-powered games, typically in the form of tokens and NFTs. However, the initial boom has given way to a severe market contraction. In the second quarter of 2025, daily unique active wallets (dUAW) in Web3 gaming fell 17% to just 4.8 million, the lowest level seen since early 2023.
This decline in user engagement has been mirrored by a collapse in venture capital funding. Investment in blockchain gaming hit just $73 million in Q2 2025, a staggering 93% year-over-year decrease. This harsh funding environment has had a devastating effect, with 93% of all GameFi projects considered dead at the end of 2024 after an average lifespan of just four months. The token performance reflects this reality, with the market cap of Play-to-Earn tokens having dropped nearly 61% year-to-date.
Transition From Play-to-Earn to Play-to-Own
The market's collapse can be largely attributed to the flaws of the original Play-to-Earn (P2E) model, which rewards players with token and NFT rewards for in-game activities. The prime example, Axie Infinity, initially saw players in some countries earning a living, but its economy proved fragile, relying on a constant influx of new players to sustain itself.
This model was fundamentally unsustainable due to several key weaknesses. Its tokenomics were built on inflation, turning games into "short-lived yield farms." Gameplay often became a grind or "shift work," prioritising financial rewards over enjoyment.
When the token rewards dried up, so did the players. The system ultimately turned players into speculators rather than gamers, creating unstable economies that were highly vulnerable to market crashes.
In response, the industry is pivoting to a more resilient model: Play-to-Own (P2O). P2O prioritises true, verifiable ownership of in-game NFT assets that have intrinsic value derived from their utility and fun gameplay, not just speculative earning potential. This approach builds more sustainable economies where value is anchored in the game's experience, the scarcity of assets, and player creativity, rather than in inflationary tokens.
By giving players a real stake in the worlds they help create, P2O fosters stronger communities and encourages long-term retention, making the game itself the primary reward. Projects like Mythical Games' NFL Rivals and FIFA Rivals exemplify this shift, focusing on polished, fun gameplay first while seamlessly integrating NFT ownership.
AI Integration and Community-Driven Development
Two key technological and social trends are shaping the future of the new GameFi model: AI's integration and the rise of community-led governance. AI is being used to create enhanced gaming experiences by powering smarter, more dynamic non-playable characters (NPCs) that can provide personalised interactions and quests.
AI is also being leveraged to help balance in-game economies by dynamically adjusting reward systems to prevent the kind of hyperinflation that plagued early P2E games. This trend is part of a larger movement toward Web3 AI agents, a market that already commands a $3.81 billion market cap as of October 24, 2025.
Alongside this, GameFi's new wave is empowering players through community-driven development. Through decentralised autonomous organisations (DAOs), projects are giving token holders the ability to vote on crucial game updates, new features, and treasury management. This gives players a real sense of ownership and aligns the incentives of both developers and the community, creating a more collaborative and sustainable ecosystem.
GameFi Regulation
The GameFi market has historically operated in a regulatory grey area, creating uncertainty for developers and investors alike as its mechanics often overlap with existing frameworks for gambling and financial securities. However, recent, seemingly unrelated legislation could bring a level of stability to the sector. The passage of the US GENIUS Act, a comprehensive stablecoin law, creates a clear framework for trusted, regulated, dollar-backed digital currencies like USDC.
This development could boost GameFi by providing a stable and compliant payments layer for the entire ecosystem. For mainstream gamers and brands, the ability to conduct in-game microtransactions, pay out tournament prizes, and purchase marketplace items using regulated stablecoins could remove the volatility risk associated with native game tokens. This increases trust and provides the reliable financial rails necessary for GameFi to safely onboard a global, mainstream audience.
The Next Level for GameFi
The GameFi industry has undergone a crucial and painful reset, forcing a move away from the unsustainable hype of Play-to-Earn. The sector's future is now being built on the more resilient Play-to-Own model, which prioritises engaging gameplay and real asset ownership over short-term speculation.
Supported by trends like AI integration, community-led governance, and clearer regulatory frameworks being established for digital payments, the sector is paving the way for a more mature and sustainable ecosystem that has the potential to attract gamers for years to come.
Ready to explore GameFi tokens?Get started on VALR today!
Risk Disclosure
Trading or investing in crypto assets is risky and may result in the loss of capital as the value may fluctuate. VALR (Pty) Ltd is a licensed financial services provider (FSP #53308).
Disclaimer: Views expressed in this article are the personal views of the author and should not form the basis for making investment decisions, nor be construed as a recommendation or advice to engage in investment transactions.